Richmond, VA
December 9–12, 2025
December 9, 2025
Joann Credle v. Virginia Community College System
Challenge to dismissal of retaliation, discrimination, and hostile work environment claims.
Sacks Holdings, Inc. v. Grin Natural USA Limited
Whether the district court erred by imposing extra-statutory requirements on the definition of "use in commerce" under 15 U.S.C. § 1127; related issues.
Heather Cogdell v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance Company
Whether district court applied correct standard of review to benefits determination where plan administrator failed to make a timely decision on appeal; other issues.
Daniel Jackson v. D. Dameron
Whether appellant properly stated a claim under the ADA and the Due Process Clause; related issues.
Jesse Near v. Enerco Group, Inc.
Whether district court erred in granting summary judgment to manufacturer on design defect claim.
Lauren Spurlock v. Wexford Health Sources, Inc.
Whether district court erred in certifying nationwide damages class of prisoners alleging failure to provide MOUD amounted to deliberate indifference; related issues.
Environmental Hydrogeological Consultants, v. North American Risk Services, Inc.
Whether district court erred in dismissing negligent misrepresentation claim, finding defendant owed plaintiff no duty of care.
Bacardi and Company Limited v. Coke Stewart
Whether district court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of US PTO in APA case seeking to set aside the Director's decision.
Legacy Spencer v. Edward Glaser, III
Whether district court erred in dismissing § 1983 claims for unlawful and excessive force and state law claims for assault, battery, and wrongful death.
Isaiah Wilkins v. Pete Hegseth
Whether district court erred enjoining military policy prohibiting accession of asymptomatic HIV-positive individuals with an undetectable viral load.
Shauntae Anderson v. William Crouch
Argument after Supreme Court remand for consideration in light of United States v. Skrmetti, 605 U. S. ___ (2025).
Nawal Ali v. BC Architects Engineers, PLC
Whether plaintiff's counsel was properly sanctioned under 28 U.S.C. § 1927; whether district court may award sanctions related to plaintiff's unsuccessful appeal.
Dominion Coal Corporation v. Director, Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs, United States Department of Labor
Center for Excellence v. Accreditation Alliance
Challenge to district court's order denying motion to vacate arbitration award; related issues.
Stephanie Redding v. Kristi Noem
Whether Plaintiff plausibly alleged she was a qualified individual for purposes of surviving motion to dismiss Rehabilitation Act claim.
L.M. v. Jonathan Graham
Whether district court properly dismissed middle school student's malicious prosecution claims arising out of allegedly false sexual assault accusation.
Raymond Richardson v. Jonathan Frame
Whether state court unreasonably resolved Appellant's claim that trial counsel rendered ineffective assistance by failing to object to alleged constructive amendment of indictment.
Eric Rich v. Daniel Hersl
Whether the magistrate judge erred in granting summary judgment to former police officer on 42 U.S.C. § 1983 false arrest and imprisonment claims.
December 10, 2025
United States v. Talten Hall, Jr.
Whether district court imposed a procedurally unreasonable sentence by not addressing or considering Hall's nonfrivolous mitigation argument regarding the conditions of his pre-trial detention.
Terrance Reeves v. Pete Hegseth
Whether district court erred in dismissing discrimination claims and granting summary judgment for defendant on retaliation and hostile work environment claims.
J. Robert van Faassen, LLM v. Greg Lindberg
Whether Dutch arbitration award is binding; timeliness of petition to confirm award; whether award is foreign-country judgment under North Carolina law.
Benny Fitzwater v. CONSOL Energy, Incorporated
Challenge to district court judgment following bench trial on claims related to employer's termination of retiree welfare benefits plan.
Garnell Walls v. Prince George's County
Whether district court erred in dismissing Fifth Amendment takings claim on ripeness grounds, concluding Burford abstention would apply if claim was ripe.
Randy Richardson v. Prince George's County
Whether district court correctly dismissed equal protection claims related to plaintiff not receiving business permit for lack of Article III standing and unripeness.
International Painters and Allied Trades Industry v. Florida Glass of Tampa Bay, Inc.
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment in favor of multi-employer pension plan in action to International Painters and Allied Trades collect withdrawal liability and additional statutory damages under ERISA.
United States v. Jonathan Otuel
Whether district court erred in denying Appellant's motion to dismiss indictment or suppress evidence based on claim that destruction of evidence violated due process.
United States v. Marcus Bland, Jr.
Whether court erred by denying motion to suppress firearm based on its finding that officers had reasonable suspicion of violation of state concealed-carry law.
Pierre Riley v. Pamela Bondi
Whether Board of Immigration Appeals erred in reversing Immigration Judge’s grant of deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture.
West Neck Community Association, Inc. v. JBWK, LLC
Cross-appeal challenging district court's interpretation of Declaration of Covenants related to permissible uses of real property.
John Doe 1 v. Office of the Director of National Intelligence
Challenge to district court's order preliminarily enjoining defendant federal agencies from terminating plaintiffs without court authorization.
Thomas Navarro v. United States Center SafeSport
Whether Amateur Sports Act unconstitutionally delegates authority to U.S. Center for Safe Sport; for related issues.
Bobby Goddard v. Michael Burnett
Whether Bankruptcy Court erred in denying confirmation of chapter 13 plan that provided for retention of three financed vehicles.
Tiffany King v. Charles Blackwood
Whether district court erred in applying Fourteenth Amendment to § 1983 claims of post-plea, pre-sentenced prisoner.
Bethany Hall v. A. Fleming
First Amendment challenge to Virginia Tuition Assistance Grant Program, which offers scholarships to Virginia college students but excepts those seeking religious vocational degrees.
United States v. James Jacobs
Whether as-applied Second Amendment challenge to charge of firearm possession by person previously convicted of domestic violence misdemeanor, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(9), is viable.
City of Southfield General Employees' Retirement v. Advance Auto Parts, Inc.
Whether plaintiff adequately alleged facts demonstrating scienter in securities fraud action. City of Southfield General Employees'
United States v. Jose Duran Garcia
Standing to challenge search; whether probable cause to search existed when drug dog did not indicate presence of drugs in accordance with its training
December 11, 2025
Ashley Cooper v. City of Wheeling
Whether district court erred in dismissing plaintiff's § 1983 claims arising from wrongful arrest.
United States v. Michael Brandon
Whether officer had reasonable suspicion to stop Defendant's vehicle based on window tint or license plate; application of good faith exception.
Deanne Haggins v. Wilson Air Center, LLC
Propriety of district court's summary judgment grant to employer on Plaintiff's ADA claim premised on failure to accommodate; related issues.
Donald Bouvet v. Illinois Union Insurance Company
United States v. Bisheem Jones
Whether Government produced sufficient evidence to convict defendant of conspiracy to commit money laundering; other issues.
Ibrahima Dieng v. Orkin, LLC
Whether district court erred in granting summary judgment for defendant employer on disability discrimination claim.
Fredis Ortez Reyes v. United States Citizenship and Immigration Services
Whether district court erred dismissing complaint for lack of jurisdiction.
Juanita Crouch v. SunCakes NC, LLC
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment for defendant employer on claims for sexual harassment, wrongful termination based on sex, retaliation, and unpaid wages.
Beltway Paving Company, Inc. v. Pruco Life Insurance Company
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment for defendants on unjust enrichment claims related to $1 million insurance payout.
Extra Energy, Incorporated v. DOWCP
Whether the ALJ erred by deferring to 20 C.F.R. § 718.305(b)(2) after Loper Bright Enters. v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024); other issues.
Stephanie Walker v. City of Charlotte, North Carolina
Whether district court erred in granting summary judgment for city, finding no issue of material fact as to plaintiff's claims of undue influence.
United States v. Amanda Tostado
Whether reversible inconsistency exists between oral pronouncement of warrantless search condition of supervised release and written judgment; proper incorporation of standing order; harmless error.
United States v. Joseph Castellano
Whether the district court abused its discretion by imposing a new supervised release condition barring the defendant from accessing legal pornography.
Kristin Simmons v. UM Capital Region Health, Inc.
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment for employer on claims under ADA for disability discrimination, under FCA and MFCA for retaliatory discharge.
Richard Harrold v. Lewis Hagen
Whether district court erred granting qualified immunity in excessive force case involving injuries inflicted by police dog.
United States v. John Moore
Whether district court erred by denying recusal motion, denying motion to suppress, ordering pro se defendant's shackling during trial, and imposing enhanced sentences.
United States v. Daqua Ritter
Whether the district court erred in denying motion for mistrial after admission of hearsay testimony during hate crime jury trial; other issues.
December 12, 2025
United States v. Jennifer McDonald
Denial of motion for mistrial based on mid-trial delays; sufficiency of evidence to sustain aggravated identity theft conviction; other issues.
United States v. Ebuka Umeti
Whether the trial evidence established that the Defendant was involved in the business email compromise schemes; other issues.
United States v. Clifton Mosley
Whether the evidence was sufficient to sustain Mosley's various witness-murder convictions; other issues.
Mandriez Spivey v. Michael Breckon
Whether plaintiff's Eighth Amendment claim that prison officers were deliberately indifferent to his medical conditions presents a new context under Bivens and Carlson.
United States v. Nathaniel Martin
Whether district court erred in denying motion to suppress firearm discovered in vehicle during traffic stop.
United States v. Nico Lowers
Whether law enforcement violated Fourth Amendment when it reviewed files identified by Google as hash matches to child sexual abuse images; other issues.
United States v. Connie Jamerson
Whether court erred by finding Jamerson in criminal contempt; whether pretrial release order under 18 U.S.C. § 3142 expires when a presentence release order under 18 U.S.C. § 3143 is issued.
John Pendarvis v. Alan Wilson
Challenge to district court's dismissal of complaint alleging constitutional violations arising from seizure and destruction of hemp crop.
United States v. Derickson Lawrence
Challenges to sufficiency of evidence regarding intent to defraud, denial of motion to sever, and sentence enhancement for use of sophisticated means.
United States v. Hatchet Speed
Whether court erred in instructing jury that device need not be operable to constitute a silencer; other issues.
United States v. Roy Cox
Whether a conviction for violating Fla. Stat. § 893.135(b)(1) (2024) qualifies as a controlled substance offense under the Sentencing Guidelines.