Richmond, VA
September 9–12, 2025
September 9, 2025
Osvaldo Figueroa v. Butterball, LLC
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment for employer on claims alleging violations of Fair Labor Standards Act, North Carolina Wage and Hour Act.
Pharmaceutical Research & Manufacturers of America v. John McCuskey
Whether district court erred in preliminarily enjoining West Virginia S.B. 325.
AbbVie, Inc. v. Anthony Brown
Whether district court erred in declining to preliminarily enjoin Maryland H.B. 1056.
Omari Mason v. Kevin Talley
Whether court erred in finding no dispute of fact related to Defendants' subjective culpability and granting summary judgment prior to discovery; other issues.
Jaime Martinez-Martinez v. Pamela Bondi
Whether, after Patel v. Garland, 596 U.S. 328 (2022), this Court may review application of the "false testimony bar" in cancellation proceedings; other issues.
Marilyn Hernandez v. Bloomingdales, LLC
Whether district court erred in concluding that Bloomingdales is not subject to specific personal jurisdiction in Maryland.
NLRB v. Constellis, LLC
Whether firearms instructor was managerial employee and thus excluded from protections of the National Labor Relations Act.
United States v. Mitchell Washington
Propriety of district court's denial of compassionate release motion based on 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a) factors, notwithstanding current inapplicability of career offender enhancement to appellant.
Gurwinder Singh v. Pamela Bondi
Whether a frivolous asylum application finding is mandatory or discretionary.
Karla Cruz De Saenz v. Pamela Bondi
Whether to re-evaluate "particularity" requirement for a social group after Loper Bright Enters. v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024); propriety of agency's alternative analysis.
Hamilton Swart, III v. Jason Miyares
Whether district court erred in granting Defendants qualified immunity on Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment claims for prolonging imprisonment based on erroneous advisory opinion.
William White v. Warden of Fed Correctional Ins - Cumberland
Whether federal inmates have a protected liberty interest in earning time credits under 18 U.S.C. § 3632(d)(4)(A); other issues.
United States v. Ibrahim Oudeh
Whether, in action under Federal Debt Collection Procedures Act, counterclaim challenging collection effort was properly dismissed based on doctrine of res judicata; related issues.
Clinchfield Coal Company v. Geraldine Mullins
Propriety of ALJ's finding that the miner's terminal arterial blood gas studies satisfied the requirements of 20 C.F.R. § 718.105(d).
United States v. Carlos Robinson
Whether an amended judgment entered after a First Step Act sentence reduction qualifies as a "new judgment" for purposes of the AEDPA.
Suhail Al Shimari v. CACI Premier Technology, Inc.
Whether district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction over claims arising under the Alien Tort Statute.
United States v. Okechukwu Dimkpa
Whether defendant showed cause or actual innocence to excuse his procedural default of claim under Ruan v. United States, 597 U.S. 450 (2022).
Carolyn Hall v. Sheppard Pratt Health System
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment in favor of defendant employer on failure to accommodate claims related to COVID-19 vaccination requirement.
Jennifer Finn v. Humane Society of the United States
Whether district court correctly found that employer's inquiry into employee's COVID-19 vaccination status is not an unlawful medical inquiry under the ADA; other issues.
September 10, 2025
Gregory Bonnie v. Warden Dunbar
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment in dispute related to calculation of "good time" credits.
Mission Integrated Technologies, LLC v. Joshua Clemente
Whether district court erred in concluding plaintiff's claims were barred by statute of limitations; related issues.
United States v. Christopher Arthur
Constitutionality of 18 U.S.C. § 842(p)(2)(B), prohibiting teaching bomb-making, knowing information will be used in furtherance of federal crime of violence; other issues.
Jawone Nicholson v. Damond Durant
Whether the district court erred in exercising supplemental jurisdiction over a state law claim for gross negligence by a private person; other issues.
United States v. Austin Lodge
Whether defendant hid or abandoned personal property; should concealment and abandonment be treated differently for Fourth Amendment purposes?
Crystal Hultz v. Frank Bisignano
Whether the ALJ's residual functional capacity assessment is supported by substantial evidence; whether the ALJ properly applied the treating physician rule.
Baby Doe v. Joshua Mast
Whether district court erred by declining to vacate or modify protective order allowing for litigation under pseudonyms; whether this court has jurisdiction over appeal.
United States v. Christon Brewer
Whether abuse of position of trust enhancement under USSG § 3B1.3 applies to defendant who merely pretends to hold position of trust.
United States v. Kevin Jones
Whether challenge to condition of supervised release delegating to probation officer determination of maximum number of drug tests is outside scope of appeal waiver.
Joseph Stanley v. Christopher Bocock
Whether district court erred in dismissing retaliatory search warrant claim.
Winnebago Tribe of Nebraska v. United States Department of the Army
Whether district court erred dismissing action seeking repatriation of remains of children from plaintiff tribe under Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act.
United States v. Richard Rund
Whether civil penalties for failing to report foreign bank and financial accounts are "fines" within the meaning of the Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause.
Mitchell Repair Information Company, LLC v. Evox Productions, LLC
Whether court properly dismissed declaratory judgment action because case with same underlying copyright dispute was already pending in California.
Jonathan R. v. Patrick Morrisey
Challenge to district court's conclusion that plaintiffs lack Article III standing to challenge West Virginia's administration of its foster care system; cross-appeal.
United States ex rel. Deborah Sheldon v. Allergan Sales, LLC
Whether district court erred granting motion to dismiss in case alleging fraud under the False Claims Act.
David Gasper v. EIDP, Inc.
Whether district court erred in granting summary judgment in favor of defendants on ERISA claims.
United States v. Augustine Perez
Whether residence is included in supervised release condition permitting warrantless searches of "person and property"; level of evidence or suspicion to confirm residence.
All American Black Car Service, Inc. v. Jamshaid Gondal
Whether bankruptcy court erred in denying setoff for unpaid compensation; related issues.
United States v. Robert Smith, Jr.
Whether defendant's guilty plea was valid and whether district court abused its discretion by denying motion to withdraw guilty plea?
United States v. Davonte Coe
Whether suppression is available remedy for Fourth Amendment excessive force violation; whether court erroneously found no causal connection between force and discovery of firearm.
September 11, 2025
Abbie Platt v. Melinda Mansfield
Whether district court erred in declining to preliminarily enjoin School Board policy prohibiting comments targeting specific students during public comments at School Board meeting.
United States v. Umar Chaudhry
Whether delay in international extradition until defendant completed foreign sentence resulted in Sixth Amendment speedy trial violation.
A&N Electric Cooperative v. Dietzel Safety Act Enterprises, Inc.
Whether the district court erred by finding indemnification claim under Virginia's Overhead High Voltage Line was barred by exemption in the Act.
United States v. Oluwatoyin Aborisade
Multi-issue challenge to visa fraud and identity theft convictions and sentence.
The Courtland Company, Inc. v. Union Carbide Corporation
Whether district court erred related to CERCLA liability, appropriate remedies, in case involving environmental violations.
The Courtland Company, Inc. v. Union Carbide Corporation
Whether district court erred in applying burden-shifting standard to determine defendant's liability under CERCLA; other issues.
September 12, 2025
United States v. Patrick Adamiak
Whether 26 U.S.C. § 5845 (National Firearms Act) is unconstitutionally vague; whether indictment failed to allege all elements of charged offenses; other issues.
United States v. Ronald Jenkins, Jr.
Whether trial evidence established the existence of an "enterprise" in prosecution for conspiracy to commit murder in aid of racketeering; other issues.
Cheryl Ann Sarver, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Gordon Jay Sarver v. Claiborne Senior Living, LLC
United States v. Danny Roney
Whether court may revoke conditional discharge under § 4243(g) based on conditions that are not part of conditionally discharged person's prescribed treatment regiment.
Christine Gibbons v. Betty Gibbs
Whether district court erred in excluding evidence of defendant's political beliefs and in excluding voir dire questions related to political bias.
United States v. Jacky McComber
Challenges to admission of summary spreadsheet, sufficiency of evidence, and loss amount in prosecution for submitting false claims in government contract.
Design Gaps, Inc. v. Distinctive Design Construction LLC
Whether district court erred in dismissing claims based on doctrine of res judicata; related issues.
United States v. Steven Lefemine
Whether defendant charged with exclusively nonviolent violation of Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, 18 U.S.C. § 248, is entitled to jury trial.
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau v. Nexus Services, Inc.
Whether the district court erred in entering default judgment and other evidentiary sanctions, granting injunctive relief, or calculating restitution.
United States v. Marian Hudak
Whether district court properly excluded defendant's mental health evidence; whether court properly admitted evidence that defendant possessed Nazi paraphernalia.
United States v. Gregory Palmer
Whether lengthy preindictment delay unfairly prejudiced defense; whether failure to inform of immigration consequence in underlying conviction taints immigration fraud conviction; other issues.
United States v. Michael Henderson
Whether the district court erred in considering the Government's objections to the presentence report and in applying the firearm enhancement under § 2D1.1(b)(1).
Reyna Alfaro-Zelaya v. Pamela Bondi
Propriety of not conducting "mixed motive" analysis given that deemed-viable protected ground underlies finding that persecutor threatened Petitioner because she refused his romantic advances.
United States v. Aaric Murray
Whether sufficient evidence supported Defendants' convictions for aiding and abetting possession of firearms in furtherance of a drug trafficking offense.
United States v. Eric Nji
Whether district court erred in excluding proffered expert testimony; propriety of jury instructions; procedural reasonableness of sentence; sufficiency of evidence; other issues.