23-1782·CIVIL
Christopher Holmes v. Elephant Insurance Company
Affirmed in Part
Status
- Scheduled
- Argued
- Opinion Issued (current)
Question Presented
Dismissal of consolidated class action under Driver's Privacy Protection Act for failure to establish Article III standing; sufficiency of injury-in-fact allegation.
Argument Date
October 29, 2024
Argument Time
9:30 a.m.
Panel
VI
Courtroom
Tan Courtroom (Room 223)
Lower Court Judge
Gibney
Panel
Judge Agee
Judge Richardson
Judge Berner
Citation
CaseChristopher Holmes v. Elephant Insurance Company, No. 23-1782 (4th Cir. Oct. 14, 2025)
PanelAgee, Richardson & Berner, JJ.
Arguing Counsel
Panel That Day
4 of 4 cases argued October 29, 2024 before this panel have been decided.
Decided
23-1782· This case
Christopher Holmes v. Elephant Insurance Company
Authored by Judge Richardson
23-2200
In re: Banco Mercantil Del Norte, S.A v. Cartograf USA, Inc.
Authored by Judge Agee
24-1158
Lynne Kritter v. Brent Mooring
Authored by Judge Berner
24-1203
Timothy Baxter v. Xavier Becerra
Authored by Judge Richardson
Opinions
- Read opinion ↗October 14, 2025Majorityby Richardson
Disposition
- Court
- Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded
- Normalized
- Affirmed in Part
October 14, 2025