21-1168·COPYRIGHT
Sony Music Entertainment; Arista Music; Arista Records, LLC; Laface Records LLC; Provident Label Group, LLC; Sony Music Entertainment US Latin LLC; Volcano Entertainment Iii, LLC; Zomba Recordings LLC; Sony/atv Music Publishing LLC; Emi Ai Gallico Music Corp.; Emi Algee Music Corp.; Emi April Music Inc.; Emi Blackwood Music Inc.; Colgems-emi Music Inc.; Emi Consortium Music Publishing Inc v. Cox Communications, Incorporated; Coxcom, LLC
Status
- Scheduled
- Argued
- Opinion Issued (current)
Question Presented
Whether internet service provider bears vicarious or contributory liability for subscribers' copyright infringement; challenge to damages amount; related issues.
Argument Date
March 9, 2022
Argument Time
2:00 p.m.
Panel
IV
Courtroom
Red Courtroom (Room 412)
Lower Court Judge
O'Grady
Panel
Judge Harris
Judge Rushing
Senior Judge Floyd
Citation
CaseSony Music Entertainment; Arista Music; Arista Records, LLC; Laface Records LLC; Provident Label Group, LLC; Sony Music Entertainment US Latin LLC; Volcano Entertainment Iii, LLC; Zomba Recordings LLC; Sony/atv Music Publishing LLC; Emi Ai Gallico Music Corp.; Emi Algee Music Corp.; Emi April Music Inc.; Emi Blackwood Music Inc.; Colgems-emi Music Inc.; Emi Consortium Music Publishing Inc v. Cox Communications, Incorporated; Coxcom, LLC, No. 21-1168 (4th Cir. Feb. 20, 2024)
PanelFloyd, S.J., Harris & Rushing, JJ.
Arguing Counsel
Panel That Day
4 of 4 cases argued March 9, 2022 before this panel have been decided.
Decided
21-1079
Eden, LLC v. Jim Justice
Authored by Judge Harris
21-1102
AJE Enterprise LLC v. James Justice
Authored by Judge Harris
21-1168· This case
Sony Music Entertainment; Arista Music; Arista Records, LLC; Laface Records LLC; Provident Label Group, LLC; Sony Music Entertainment US Latin LLC; Volcano Entertainment Iii, LLC; Zomba Recordings LLC; Sony/atv Music Publishing LLC; Emi Ai Gallico Music Corp.; Emi Algee Music Corp.; Emi April Music Inc.; Emi Blackwood Music Inc.; Colgems-emi Music Inc.; Emi Consortium Music Publishing Inc v. Cox Communications, Incorporated; Coxcom, LLC
21-1868
Jonathan R. v. Jim Justice
Authored by Senior Judge Floyd
Opinions
- Read opinion ↗Majority
- Read opinion ↗February 20, 2024Majority