19-6655·CIVIL RIGHTS

Vernon Norman Earle v. Shreves, C/o; J. Rivera, Unit Manager for M-Unit at Fci Hazelton; R. Domas, Unit Manager for L-Unit; D. Washington, Operating Lieutenant; Mr. Gonoundy, [sia] Special Investigative Agent; Mr. Breckon, Assistant Warden of Operations; Rachel Thompson, Administrative assistant/Remedy Coordinator; Jennifer Saad, Warden of Fci Hazelton; K. Kelly, Captain of Fci Hazelton; A. Gyorko, Case manager for Unit N-2 and for Plaintiff Directly; C. T. Pulice, Case Manager Coordinator; J. F. Caraway, Mid-Atlantic Regional Director; Ian Connors, National Inmates Appeals Administrator; Mr. Squires, [sis] special investigative Service Lieutenant

Affirmed

Status

Scheduled
Argued
Opinion Issued (current)

Question Presented

Whether Bivens remedy is available in light of Ziglar v. Abbasi, 137 S. Ct. 1843 (2017); propriety of grant of summary judgment; other issues.

Argument Date

December 9, 2020

Panel

Lower Court Judge

Bailey

Panel

Judge Keenan

Judge Richardson

Senior Judge Traxler

Citation

CaseVernon Norman Earle v. Shreves, C/o; J. Rivera, Unit Manager for M-Unit at Fci Hazelton; R. Domas, Unit Manager for L-Unit; D. Washington, Operating Lieutenant; Mr. Gonoundy, [sia] Special Investigative Agent; Mr. Breckon, Assistant Warden of Operations; Rachel Thompson, Administrative assistant/Remedy Coordinator; Jennifer Saad, Warden of Fci Hazelton; K. Kelly, Captain of Fci Hazelton; A. Gyorko, Case manager for Unit N-2 and for Plaintiff Directly; C. T. Pulice, Case Manager Coordinator; J. F. Caraway, Mid-Atlantic Regional Director; Ian Connors, National Inmates Appeals Administrator; Mr. Squires, [sis] special investigative Service Lieutenant, No. 19-6655 (4th Cir. Mar. 10, 2021)

PanelTraxler, S.J., Keenan & Richardson, JJ.