Richmond, VA
May 5–9, 2025
May 5, 2025
May 6, 2025
United States v. Richard Smith, Jr.
Whether district court abused its discretion by denying motion for compassionate release, including declining to consider stacked 18 U.S.C. SECTION 924(c) sentence.
Deborah Parker v. Dan Martin
Whether district court erred in overturning the bankruptcy court's finding that debt was nondischargeable under 11 U.S.C. § 534(a)(4) based on debtor's embezzlement of funds.
Sage Blair v. Appomattox County School Board
Challenge to district court's dismissal of claims on qualified immunity grounds.
Bank of America Corporation, f/k/a NationsBank, f/k/a BankAmerica Corporation, f/k/a FleetBoston Financial Corporation, f/k/a BankBoston Corporation, f/k/a Summit Bancorp, f/k/a Mbna Corporation, f/k/a Merrill Lynch & Company, Incorporated v. United States of America
Whether surviving corporation following merger can net the interest on underpayment and overpayment by merged corporations.
Towers Watson & Co. v. National Union Fire Insurance Company
Whether D&O policy's bump-up exclusion applied to preclude indemnification in shareholder litigation challenging merger.
Robbie Plyler v. Russell Cox
Whether district court erred in denying motion for judgment as a matter of law on last clear chance; other issues.
Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America; Netchoice; Computer & Communications Industry Association v. Brooke E. Lierman
Whether pass-through provision of Maryland Digital Advertising Gross Revenues Tax Act violates Chamber of Commerce of the United States the First Amendment.
Robert Frazier v. Prince Georges County
Whether district court erred in granting quasi-judicial immunity to Prince George's County; other issues.
Genovevo Alvarez Ronquillo v. Pamela Bondi
Whether a federal conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1)(A) qualifies, categorically, as an aggravated felony under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(43)(C).
United States v. Andrew Krueger
Whether district court erred in denying defendant's motion to suppress evidence gathered from search of electronic devices seized from his home.
Randy Luna v. Tug Hill Operating, LLC
Whether court correctly applied Rogers v. Tug Hill Operating, LLC, 76 F.4th 279 (4th Cir. 2023), in denying motion to compel arbitration; other issues.
Geri-Care Pharmaceuticals Corporation v. Stradis Healthcare, LLC
Whether the district court erred in granting summary judgment to cotortfeasor on Maryland common law indemnification claim but denying claim for attorney's fees.
John Moretti v. Helga Thorsdottir
Whether malicious prosecution action was properly dismissed for failure to allege plausible claim and based on grant of qualified immunity.
Ted Acord v. Chad Stilley
Xyavier Calliste v. Xeng Lor
Whether district court erred denying qualified immunity related to officer's use of deadly force.
Justin Wolfe v. Chadwick Dotson
Whether district court erred in concluding that evidence presented during habeas proceedings was not "new" for purposes of establishing actual innocence.
Ann deWet v. G. Rollyson, Jr.
Whether Deputy Commissioner is entitled to qualified immunity in suit alleging due process violations related to tax sale.
Mary Shumate v. City of Lynchburg
Whether district court erred in concluding that individual Defendants were entitled to sovereign immunity and whether court correctly dismissed Plaintiff's Title VII retaliation claim.
United States v. Kevin Sandoval
Whether flawed interpretation of Spanish-speaking witnesses' testimony violated Confrontation Clause or Due Process Clause; other issues.
Brian Fernaays v. Isle of Wight County
Challenge to district court's grant of summary judgment to county in inverse condemnation action.
May 7, 2025
Gray Media Group, Inc. v. Heather Loveridge
Whether this court possesses jurisdiction to decide WBTV's appeal; whether district court possessed jurisdiction to decide WBTV's motion to intervene.
Izuchukwu Ozurumba v. Pamela Bondi
Whether petitioner provided "material support" to a terrorist organization such that he may not qualify for asylum under the INA.
Jackson Creek Marine, LLC v. State of Maryland
Whether Limitation of Liability Act of 1851 is applicable to allow district court to require a state to bring any claims in the limitation proceeding.
Nicholas Cupp v. Delta Air Lines, Inc.
Whether immunity under Va. Code Ann. § 63.2-1512 was properly applied when child abuse was not reported to local department of social services.
East Coast Storage Equipment Co Inc v. ZF Transmissions Gray Court LLC
Challenge to district court's grant of summary judgment where parties dispute existence and terms of contract and Plaintiff sought equitable remedies.
Edward Williams v. Fairfax County Government
Whether district court erred in granting summary judgment for employer in sexual orientation discrimination, hostile work environment, and retaliation claims.
United States v. James Jones, Jr.
Sufficiency of evidence to establish willful or corrupt action; applicability of USSG § 2T1.1(b)(1) regarding source of income exceeding $10,000; other issues.
GW Acquisition Co., LLC v. Pageland Limited William County Digital Gateway Project; Liability Company
Propriety of district court's dismissal and summary judgment rulings relative to disputes arising out of Prince attorney's fee ruling.
United States v. Duane Berry
Constitutionality of provision in 18 U.S.C. § 4246(a) permitting certification for civil commitment following dismissal of criminal charges; other issues.
United States v. Ricky Artis
Whether the district court reversibly erred by imposing a broader search condition of supervised release on remand for resentencing; other issues.
Kimberly Lafave v. County of Fairfax, Virginia
Challenge to county ordinance prohibiting possession of firearms in public parks and locations where people gather pursuant to a government permit.
Susannah Kipke v. Wes Moore
Cross-appeal related to district court's upholding Maryland firearm restrictions applicable to certain locations and finding unconstitutional restrictions related to certain locations.
Lula Williams v. Matt Martorello
Whether internet lending by tribally owned company constitutes "off-reservation" activity to which state law applies.
Leah Hollis v. Morgan State University
Appeal from district court's grant of summary judgment in favor of employer on discrimination, retaliation, and equal protection claims.
Rise for Animals v. Gary Washington
Whether district court lacked jurisdiction to consider plaintiff's claims challenging USDA facility inspection policy under the Animal Welfare Act.
Joel Burrell v. D. Shirley
Whether Younger dismissal and dismissal for failure to comply with order to file amended complaint stating valid claim count as strikes under § 1915(g).
Wilbert Finley v. Kraft Heinz Inc.
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment for employer on Food Safety Modernization Act retaliation claim.
May 8, 2025
Jane Roe v. Marshall University Board of Governors
Appeal from grant of summary judgment in favor of university on Title IX deliberate indifference claim.
Bestwall LLC v. Official Committee of Asbestos Claimants
Whether bankruptcy court lacked jurisdiction over voluntary petition where debtor is not in financial distress.
Walmart Real Estate Business Trust; Sam's Real Estate Business Trust v. Quarterfield Partners LLC; Bl Quarterfield Associates LLC; Q.o.p. Properties LLC; Quarterfield Office Park LLC
Commercial real estate dispute involving whether valid option existed in lease agreements, whether breach occurred, whether option was validly exercised; other related issues.
Lynn Freeman v. Progressive Direct Insurance Company
Whether the district court erred in granting class certification under Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(b)(3) on breach of contract claims.
Makina ve Kimya Endustrisi A.S. v. Kutlay Kaya
Whether district court erred in denying post-trial motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict and for a new trial.
PACEM Solutions International, LLC v. U. S. Small Business Administration
Whether district court erred finding the SBA did not act in an arbitrary, capricious or illegal manner in decision to stop payments under CARES Act subsidy program.
Columbia Gas Transmission, LLC v. RDFS, LLC
Whether district court erred granting injunctive relief and partial summary judgment related to mitigation work to be performed within a natural gas easement.
E.R. v. Beaufort County School District
Whether district court erred dismissing plaintiff's Title IX claims as untimely.
United States v. Brandon Jackson
Constitutionality of 18 U.S.C. § 922(n) following Bruen.
Skyline Tower Painting, Inc v. Elizabeth L. Goldberg
Priority 1 Automotive Group, Inc. v. CDK Global, LLC
Whether plaintiff's breach of contract and unjust enrichment claims were time-barred under Maryland's statute of limitations.
United States v. Eric Johnson
Whether canine sniff in interior, common hallway outside apartment door violated the Fourth Amendment.
Eliza Wille v. Jeremy Pelter
Whether promulgation of rule related to human interaction with spinner dolphins was promulgated in violation of the Appointments Clause.
Cross River Bank v. 3 Bea’s Assisted Living LLC, a/k/a Three Bea's Assisted Living, a Maryland Limited Liability Company; Connie Stewart; David Stewart, Jr
Whether promissory note is ambiguous under Maryland law regarding capacity in which borrower signed note.
Terrence Hammock v. Gail Watts
Challenge to district court's dismissal of conditions of confinement claim related to rotten and contaminated food served to inmates; other issues.
Amanda Smith v. Mark Averill
Appeal from grant of summary judgment for employer on claims related to disability discrimination and failure to accommodate under the Rehabilitation Act; related issues.
Saadiq Long v. Pamela Bondi
Whether appellant has standing to challenge inclusion on Terrorism Watch List.
United States v. Keith Bell
Whether appellate waiver applies to amended judgment entered after grant of § 2255 relief and vacatur of one count of conviction; enforceability of waiver.
May 9, 2025
United States v. Carl Mann, II
Multiple issues raised in consolidated criminal case involving multiple defendants, including evidentiary and speedy trial issues.
Salomon & Ludwin, LLC v. Jeremiah Winters
Challenge to preliminary injunction in case alleging state and federal trade secret violations.
Jesse Hammons v. University of Maryland Medical System Corporation
Whether there is jurisdiction over 23-1394; whether cancellation of gender-affirming surgery violates First or Fourteenth Amendments or Affordable Care Act.
Sandra Gardner v. International Association of Machinists
Challenge to district court's denial of plaintiff's application for leave to file complaint for breach of fiduciary duty under 29 U.S.C. § 501(b).
Sysco Machinery Corporation v. DCS USA Corporation
Challenge to district court's dismissal of misappropriate of trade secrets and other claims under the Defend Trade Secrets Act and Copyright Act.
Michael Holt v. Ted Hull
Challenge to grant of summary judgment in case alleging constitutional violations stemming from facility's refusal to transfer inmate's time-served credit to subsequent facility.
Houston Casualty Company v. Trident Construction Services, LLC
Whether district court erred granting summary judgment for insurer in dispute related to coverage, whether certain exceptions applied; related issues.
Anthony Kelly v. City of Alexandria
Whether district court erred in concluding Fire Department Battalion Chiefs were exempt from FLSA overtime requirements.
Dr. Muthoni Imungi v. Virginia Commonwealth University
Whether district court properly awarded summary judgment to university on professor's Title VII retaliation claim related to removal from director position.
George Hawkins v. Glenn Youngkin
First Amendment challenge to Virginia's voting rights restoration system.
A. Philip Randolph Institute v. North Carolina State Board of Elections
Whether plaintiff's claims challenging statute became moot after legislature passed amended statute.
State of West Virginia ex rel. Mark A. Hunt v. CaremarkPCS Health, L.L.C.
Whether district court erred in remanding case to state court, finding federal officer removal was unavailable.
Ernest Chappell v. TruckPro, LLC
Whether plaintiff's evidence that defendant distributed allegedly defective product was sufficient under South Carolina products liability law.